Thursday, February 18, 2010

Task 3

In terms of what I noticed about blog writing in general, it seems more inter-connected. By that I mean that it is hard to just read a part in isolation, since one post references another and so on. I was surprised to find that the language was more grammatically correct than I expected. I thought it might be more text-speaky. I've always thought of blogs as what whiny people with too much time on their hands do, and I didn't see how they'd be professionally helpful. I'm getting a better sense of that now.

The blog I found the most useful for my purposes was the Woodward site on EXTREMELY LOUD & INCREDIBLY CLOSE. It provided a great template of how to set up a blog on a book. It seems like the kids were using class time to do many of their posts, since they were all around the same time during the school day. Many of them commented that it was such a relief to have a change of pace, after sitting through discussion classes all day. I just wish I could find a general description of the requirements for the kids - how many posts in which categories.

I'm thinking of doing a similar thing with A SEPARATE PEACE, which we will be starting in a few weeks. Once we have our netbooks, it will be much easier, but I suppose we could set up in the lab. I wouldn't want to totally give up discussion, but I would like to incorporate blogging in lieu of discussion sometimes - I am especially curious to see what the quieter kids have to say.

2 comments:

  1. If you get a chance, include a link to your Separate Peace blog...I'd love for others to see what you have done!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also like the idea of class blogs about a certain book (or about history or vocabulary or whatever), but there are a few things I'm skeptical about. On these sample blogs the kids all sound so intelligent and articulate and engaged in their posts and I don't see how the mere act of typing your comments on a computer would create that. Is the teacher imposing specific guidelines about how much they blog, or are they being graded on the quantity and quality of what they write? I imagine a lot of our kids doing what they do on First Class forums -- typing in one and two word responses, getting off track and writing goofy stuff, etc. Once the novelty wears off, I find it hard to believe that their level of engagement will be any higher than it would be in other mediums. And I worry about the kids who really can't express themselves in writing very well. I have kids this year who can barely write a coherent sentence, and for some of them, posting their incoherent sentences for all the world to see would be quite humiliating.

    ReplyDelete